Dave Meltzer Ratings Thread

[Misawa~]

NXT Deadl1ne 2023 (09.12.2023)
- Axiom vs Nathan Frazer: 4 Stars
- Dominik Mysterio © vs Dragon Lee (NXT North American Title Match): 3.25 Stars
- Women's Iron Survivor Challenge Match: 3.25 Stars
- Carmelo Hayes vs Lexis King: 3 Stars
- Men's Iron Survivor Challenge Match: 4.5 Stars
- Kiana James vs Roxanne Perez (Steel Cage Match): 2.5 Stars
- Ilja Dragunov © vs Baron Corbin (NXT Title Match): 3.5 Stars

WWE RAW (11.12.2023)
- Drew McIntyre vs Jey Uso: 3.75 Stars

AEW Dynamite #219 (13.12.2023)
- Adam Page vs Roderick Strong: 4.25 Stars
- Andrade El Idolo vs Brody King (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4 Stars
- Jay White vs Mark Briscoe (Continental Classic Gold League Match): 3.75 Stars
- Jon Moxley vs Swerve Strickland (Continental Classic Gold League Match): 4.5 Stars

AEW Rampage #123 (15.12.2023)
- Action Andretti & Top Flight (Dante Martin & Darius Martin) vs El Hijo del Vikingo, Komander & Penta El Zero Miedo: 4.75 Stars

CMLL Super Viernes (15.12.2023)
- Rocky Romero © vs Mascara Dorada (World Historic Welterweight Title Match): 4.5 Stars
- Andrade El Idolo, Angel de Oro & Soberano Jr. vs Atlantis Jr., Mistico & Star Jr. (2 out of 3 Falls Trios Match): 4 Stars

ROH Final Battle 2023 (15.12.2023)
- Jazmin Allure vs Taya Valkyrie: 1 Stars
- The Outrunners (Truth Magnum & Turbo Floyd) vs The Von Erichs (Marshall Von Erich & Ross Von Erich): 1.25 Stars
- Bryan Keith vs Jack Cartwheel (ROH World Television Title Survival of the Fittest 2023 Qualifying Match): 3.25 Stars
- Blake Christian vs Daniel Garcia: 3.5 Stars
- El Hijo del Vikingo © vs Black Taurus (AAA Mega Title Match): 4.5 Stars
- The Mogul Embassy © vs TMDK (ROH World Six Man Tag Team Titles Match: 3.75 Stars
- Ethan Page vs Tony Nese (I Quit Match): 4.25 Stars
- Nyla Rose vs Vertvixen: 0.75 Stars
- ROH World Television Title & Survival of the Fittest 2023 Match: 4.75 Stars
- Wheeler Yuta © vs Tom Lawlor (ROH Pure Title Match): 3.5 Stars
- Keith Lee vs Shane Taylor: 2.5 Stars
- The Blackpool Combat Club vs FTR & Mark Briscoe: 4.75 Stars
- Anthony Henry vs Eddie Kingston: 2.5 Stars
- Athena © vs Billie Starkz (ROH Women's World Title Match): 4.25 Stars

AEW Collision #27 (16.12.2023)
- Andrade El Idolo vs Claudio Castagnoli (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.25 Stars
- Orange Cassidy © vs Bryan Keith (AEW International Title Match): 3.5 Stars
- Daniel Garcia vs Eddie Kingston (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.25 Stars
- Brody King vs Bryan Danielson (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.5 Stars

RevPro Uprising 2023 (16.12.2023)
- Gabe Kidd vs Will Ospreay: 4.25 Stars

WWE RAW (18.12.2023)
- Gunther © vs The Miz (WWE Intercontinental Title Match): 4.25 Stars
- The Judgment Day (Damian Priest & Finn Balor) © vs The Creed Brothers (Brutus Creed & Julius Creed) (Undisputed WWE Tag Team Titles Match): 3.75 Stars

AEW Dynamite #220 (20.12.2023)
- Rush vs Swerve Strickland (Continental Classic Gold League Match): 4 Stars
- Jay Lethal vs Mark Briscoe (Continental Classic Gold League Match): 3.75 Stars
- Jay White vs Jon Moxley (Continental Classic Gold League Match): 4 Stars

[Misawa~]

AEW Rampage #122 (08.12.2023)
- Bryan Danielson vs Daniel Garcia (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.5 Stars

NJPW Road to Tokyo Dome 2023 Day 1 (21.12.2023)
- Hiroshi Tanahashi, Kazuchika Okada & Tomohiro Ishii © vs The United Empire (Great-o-Khan, HENARE & Jeff Cobb) (NEVER Openweight Six Man Tag Team Titles Match): 4.75 Stars

AEW Rampage #124 (22.12.2023)
- El Hijo del Vikingo © vs Black Taurus (AAA Mega Title Match): 4.5 Stars

WWE SmackDown (22.12.2023)
- Dragon Lee © vs Butch (NXT North American Title Match): 3.75 Stars

AEW Collision #28 (23.12.2023)
- Bryan Danielson vs Claudio Castagnoli (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.25 Stars
- Brian Cage vs Keith Lee: 3.5 Stars
- Brody King vs Daniel Garcia (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 3.75 Stars
- Andrade El Idolo vs Eddie Kingston (Continental Classic Blue League Match): 4.25 Stars

NXT (26.12.2023)
- Bron Breakker vs Nathan Frazer: 3.75 Stars
- Dijak vs Eddy Thorpe (NXT Underground Match): 4 Stars

AEW Dynamite #221 (27.12.2023)
- Jay White vs Jon Moxley vs Swerve Strickland (Continental Classic Gold League Final 3 Way Match): 4.5 Stars
- Bryan Danielson vs Eddie Kingston (Continental Classic Blue League Final Match): 4.75 Stars

[Misawa~]

CMLL Super Viernes (29.12.2023)
- Andrade El Idolo vs Volador Jr.: 4.25 Stars

AEW Worlds End 2023 (30.12.2023)
- Kris Statlander vs Willow Nightingale: 2 Stars
- AEW TNT Title Number One Contender Battle Royal: 2 Stars
- Hook © vs Wheeler Yuta (FTW Title FTW Rules Match): 3.25 Stars
- Brody King, Jay Lethal, Jay White & Rush vs Bryan Danielson, Claudio Castagnoli, Daniel Garcia & Mark Briscoe: 4.5 Stars
- Andrade El Idolo vs Miro: 4 Stars
- Toni Storm © vs Riho (AEW Women's World Title Match): 3.5 Stars
- Dustin Rhodes vs Swerve Strickland: 3.25 Stars
- Big Bill, Konosuke Takeshita, Powerhouse Hobbs & Ricky Starks vs Chris Jericho, Darby Allin, Sammy Guevara & Sting: 2.5 Stars
- Julia Hart © vs Abadon (AEW TBS Title Match): 1.25 Stars
- Christian Cage © vs Adam Copeland (AEW TNT Title No DQ Match): 4.75 Stars
- Eddie Kingston vs Jon Moxley (AEW Continental Title + NJPW STRONG Openweight Title + ROH World Title + Continental Classic 2023 Final Match): 4.75 Stars
- MJF © vs Samoa Joe (AEW World Title Match): 3.5 Stars

AJPW Mania X 2023 (31.12.2023)
- Katsuhiko Nakajima © vs Kento Miyahara (Triple Crown Title Match): 5.25 Stars

WWE RAW - Day 1 2024 (01.01.2024)
- Becky Lynch vs Nia Jax: 3.5 Stars
- Seth Rollins © vs Drew McIntyre (WWE World Heavyweight Title Match): 4.25 Stars

NOAH The New Year 2024 (02.01.2024)
- Masa Kitamiya vs Tomohiro Ishii: 4.75 Stars

AEW Dynamite #222 (03.01.2024)
- Orange Cassidy © vs Dante Martin (AEW International Title Match): 3.5 Stars
- Darby Allin vs Konosuke Takeshita: 4.5 Stars
- Brian Cage vs Bryan Keith vs El Hijo del Vikingo vs Trent Beretta (AEW Continental Title Number One Contender 4 Way Match): 3.5 Stars
- Daniel Garcia vs Swerve Strickland: 3.75 Stars

NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 18 (04.01.2024)
- New Japan Rambo: 2 Stars
- Clark Connors & Drilla Moloney © vs Francesco Akira & TJP (IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Titles Match): 3.5 Stars
- Zack Sabre Jr. © vs Hiroshi Tanahashi (NJPW World Television Title Match): 4 Stars
- Yota Tsuji vs Yuya Uemura: 4 Stars
- EVIL & Ren Narita vs Kaito Kiyomiya & Shota Umino: 2.75 Stars
- Shingo Takagi © vs Tama Tonga (NEVER Openweight Title Match): 4.5 Stars
- Hirooki Goto & YOSHI-HASHI © vs Hikuleo & El Phantasmo © (IWGP Tag Team Titles + NJPW STRONG Openweight Tag Team Titles Match): 3.75 Stars
- Hiromu Takahashi © vs El Desperado (IWGP Junior Heavyweight Title Match): 4 Stars
- David Finlay vs Jon Moxley vs Will Ospreay (IWGP Global Heavyweight Title 3 Way Match): 4.75 Stars
- Bryan Danielson vs Kazuchika Okada: 5.25 Stars
- SANADA © vs Tetsuya Naito (IWGP World Heavyweight Title Match): 4.5 Stars

[Misawa~]

STARDOM Ittenyon Stardom Gate 2024 (04.01.2024)
- Mayu Iwatani © vs Syuri (IWGP Women's Title Match): 4.75 Stars
("For those curious, he basically said he would have given Mayu/Syuri the full 5 if they hadn't done the headbutt spots. Said it's a legit MOTYC.")

NJPW New Year Dash 2024 (05.01.2024)
- The Blackpool Combat Club (Bryan Danielson & Jon Moxley) & CHAOS (Kazuchika Okada & Tomohiro Ishii) vs TMDK (Kosei Fujita, Mikey Nicholls, Shane Haste & Zack Sabre Jr.): 3.5 Stars

WWE SmackDown (05.01.2024)
- Kevin Owens vs Santos Escobar (WWE United States Title Number One Contender Tournament Final Match): 4 Stars
- IYO SKY © vs Michin (WWE Women's Title Match): 3.5 Stars

AEW Collision #29 (06.01.2024)
- Eddie Kingston © vs Trent Beretta (AEW Continental Title + NJPW STRONG Openweight Title + ROH World Title Match): 4.25 Stars
- FTR (Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood) vs The House of Black (Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black): 4.5 Stars

WWE RAW (08.01.2024)
- Cody Rhodes vs Shinsuke Nakamura (Street Fight Match): 3.5 Stars

AEW Dynamite #223 - Homecoming 2024 (10.01.2024)
- Adam Page vs Claudio Castagnoli: 4.25 Stars
- Darby Allin & Sting vs The Don Callis Family (Konosuke Takeshita & Powerhouse Hobbs) (Tornado Tag Team Match): 4 Stars

[Misawa~]

CMLL Super Viernes (05.01.2024)
- Mascara Dorado vs Templario (2 out of 3 Falls Match): 5 Stars

DG Open The New Year Gate 2024 Day 4 (10.01.2024)
- Masaaki Mochizuki vs Shingo Takagi: 4.5 Stars

[b]WWE SmackDown (12.01.2024)
- Legado World Order vs LWO: 3.5 Stars

AEW Battle of the Belts IX (13.01.2024)
- Big Bill & Ricky Starks © vs Chris Jericho & Sammy Guevara (AEW World Tag Team Titles Street Fight Match): 4.25 Stars

AEW Collision #30 (13.01.2024)
- The Mogul Embassy © vs Lance Archer & The Rightous (ROH World Six Man Tag Team Titles): 3.5 Stars
- Adam Page vs JD Drake: 4 Stars
- Daniel Garcia & FTR vs The House of Black: 4.5 Stars

NJPW Battle in the Valley 2024 (13.01.2024)
- Stephanie Vanquer vs Viva Van (NJPW STRONG Women's Title Number One Contender Match): 1.5 Stars
- Fred Rosser, Jacob Fatu & Shota Umino vs Team Filthy (Jorel Nelson, Royce Isaacs & Tom Lawlor): 3 Stars
- Mascara Dorada & Volador Jr. vs Rocky Romero & Soberano Jr.: 3.75 Stars
- David Finlay vs TJP: 3.75 Stars
- The Guerrillas of Destiny (Hikuleo & El Phantasmo) © vs BULLET CLUB War Dogs (Alex Coughlin & Clark Connors) (NJPW STRONG Openweight Tag Team Titles Match): 3.5 Stars
- Giulia © vs Trish Adora (NJPW STRONG Women's Title Match): 4 Stars
- The Chosen Bros (Jeff Cobb & Matt Riddle) vs TMDK (Bad Dude Tito & Zack Sabre Jr.): 4.25 Stars
- Eddie Kingston © vs Gabe Kidd (AEW Continental Title + NJPW STRONG Openweight Title + ROH World Title Match): 4.5 Stars
- Jon Moxley vs Shingo Takagi (No DQ Match): 5 Stars
- Kazuchika Okada vs Will Ospreay: 5 Stars

NOAH Star Navigation 2024 (13.01.2024):
- Kenoh © vs Go Shiozaki (GHC Heavyweight Title Match): 4.75 Stars

TNA Hard to Kill 2024 (13.01.2024)
- Rich Swann vs Steve Maclin: 3.25 Stars
- Eric Young & Frankie Kazarian vs The System (Brian Myers & Eddie Edwards): 3 Stars
- TNA Knockout's World Title Number One Contender Ultimate X Match: 3 Stars
- Alpha Bravo, Dirty Dango & Oleg Prudius vs Jake Something, PCO & Rhino: 1 Star
- MK Ultra (Killer Kelly & Masha Slamovich) © vs The Decay (Havok & Rosemary) (TNA Knockout's World Tag Team Match): 1.25 Stars
- Chris Sabin © vs El Hijo del Vikingo vs KUSHIDA (TNA X-Division Title 3 Way Match): 4.25 Stars
- Alex Hammerstone vs Josh Alexander: 3.75 Stars
- TNA World Tag Team Titles 4 Way Match: 4.25 Stars
- Trinity © vs Jordynne Grace (TNA Knockout's World Title Match): 2.75 Stars
- Alex Shelley © vs Moose (TNA World Title Match): 3.75 Stars

WWE RAW (15.01.2024)
- DIY (Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa) vs The Judgment Day (Dominik Mysterio & JD McDonagh): 3.5 Stars

AEW Dynamite #224 (17.01.2024):
- Komander & Penta El Zero Miedo vs Orange Cassidy & Rocky Romero: 3.5 Stars

[Misawa~]

TNA Impact (18.01.2024)
- Josh Alexander vs Will Ospreay: 5.5 Stars

AEW Rampage #128 (19.01.2024)
- Darby Allin vs Jeff Hardy: 4 Stars

CMLL Super Viernes (19.01.2024)
- Felino Jr. vs Valiante Jr.: 3.25 Stars
- Los Depredadores (Magnus & Rugido) vs Futuro & Neon: 4 Stars
- El Barbaro Cavernario vs Mascara Dorada: 4.25 Stars

AEW Collision #31 (20.01.2024)
- Jon Moxley vs Shane Taylor: 3.5 Stars
- Buddy Matthews vs Daniel Garcia: 4 Stars
- The Blackpool Combat Club (Bryan Danielson & Claudio Castagnoli) vs Eddie Kingston & Ortiz: 4.25 Stars

WWE RAW (22.01.2024)
- Chad Gable vs Ivar: 4 Stars

NXT (23.01.2024)
- Axiom & Nathan Frazer vs Baron Corbin & Bron Breakker (Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic 2024 Semi Final Match): 4.25 Stars

AEW Dynamite #225 (24.01.2024)
- Adam Page vs Penta El Zero Miedo: 4 Stars
- Jeff Hardy vs Swerve Strickland: 3.5 Stars
- Adam Copeland vs Minoru Suzuki: 3.5 Stars

NJPW Road To The New Beginning 2024 Day 3 (24.01.2024)
- Hiroshi Tanahashi, Kazuchika Okada & Tomohiro Ishii © vs TMDK (Kosei Fujita, Mikey Nicholls & Shane Haste) (NEVER Openweight Six Man Tag Team Titles): 4.25 Stars

[Misawa~]

AEW Collision #32 (27.01.2024)
- The Blackpool Combat Club (Claudio Castagnoli & Jon Moxley) vs Shane Taylor Promotions (Lee Moriarty & Shane Taylor): 3.5 Stars
- Orange Cassidy © vs Komander (AEW International Title Match): 3.75 Stars
- Bryan Danielson vs Yuji Nagata: 4.25 Stars
- Daniel Garcia & FTR (Cash Wheeler & Dax Harwood) vs The House of Black (Brody King, Buddy Matthews & Malakai Black) (Steel Cage Escape Trios Match): 4.5 Stars

WWE Royal Rumble 2024 (27.01.2024)
- Women's Royal Rumble Match: 3 Stars
- Roman Reigns © vs AJ Styles vs LA Knight vs Randy Orton (Undisputed WWE Universal Title Match): 3 Stars
- Logan Paul © vs Kevin Owens (WWE United States Title Match: 3.5 Stars
- Men's Royal Rumble Match: 4.25 Stars

WWE RAW (29.01.2024)
- The Judgment Day (Damian Priest & Finn Balor) © vs DIY (Johnny Gargano & Tommaso Ciampa) (Undisputed WWE Tag Team Titles Match): 3.75 Stars
- Gunther © vs Kofi Kingston (WWE Intercontinental Title Match): 3.75 Stars
- Drew McIntyre vs Sami Zayn: 3.75 Stars

NXT (30.01.2024)
- Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams vs LWO (Cruz del Toro & Joaquin Wilde) (Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic 2024 Semi Final Match): 4 Stars

AEW Dynamite #226 (31.01.2024)
- Adam Page vs Toa Liona: 4 Stars

[Misawa~]

CMLL Super Viernes (02.02.2024)
- Brillante Jr. & Mistico vs Mascara Dorada & Neon (Gran Alternativa 2024 Final Match): 4.25 Stars

AEW Collision #33 (03.02.2024)
- Bryan Keith vs Eddie Kingston (Proving Ground Match): 4 Stars
- Bryan Danielson vs Hechicero: 4.5 Stars
- Daniel Garcia & FTR vs The Patriarchy: 4 Stars

NXT Vengeance Day 2024 (04.02.2024)
- Baron Corbin & Bron Breakker vs Carmelo Hayes & Trick Williams (Dusty Rhodes Classic 2024 Final Match): 3.5 Stars
- Dijak vs Joe Gacy (No DQ Match): 3.25 Stars
- The Family vs Out the Mud: 2.25 Stars
- Lyra Valkyria © vs Lola Vice vs Roxanne Perez (NXT Women's Title Triple Threat Match): 2.75 Stars
- Oba Femi © vs Dragon Lee (NXT North American Title Match): 2.5 Stars
- Ilja Dragunov © vs Trick Williams (NXT Title Match): 4 Stars

WWE RAW (05.02.2024)
- The Creed Brothers vs DIY vs Imperium vs The New Day (Undisputed WWE Tag Team Titles Number One Contender Fatal Four Way Match): 3.75 Stars
- Cody Rhodes vs Shinsuke Nakamura (Bull Rope Match): 3.5 Stars

NXT (06.02.2024)
- Axiom & Nathan Frazer vs Edris Enofe & Malik Blade: 4.25 Stars
- Dijak vs Ilja Dragunov: 3.75 Stars

AEW Dynamite #227 (07.02.2024)
- Adam Page vs Swerve Strickland (AEW World Title Number One Contender Match): 4.5 Stars
- The Blackpool Combat Club vs Hechicero, Mascara Dorada & Volador Jr.: 4.25 Stars
- Chris Jericho vs Konosuke Takeshita: 4.25 Stars
- Big Bill & Ricky Starks © vs Darby Allin & Sting (AEW World Tag Team Titles Tornado Match): 4.25 Stars

[Misawa~]

WWE SmackDown (09.02.2024)
- AJ Styles vs Drew McIntyre (Elimination Chamber Qualifying Match): 3.5 Stars
- Randy Orton vs Sami Zayn (Elimination Chamber Qualifying Match): 3.5 Stars

AEW Collision #34 (10.02.2024)
- Brody King vs Mark Briscoe: 3.5 Stars

NJPW The New Beginning in Osaka 2024 (11.02.2024)
- Bishamon (Hirooki Goto & YOSHI-HASHI) vs The United Empire (Callum Newman & Great-O-Khan): 3 Stars
- El Desperado, Shota Umino, Tiger Mask IV & Tomoaki Honma vs House of Torture: 2.5 Stars
- Los Ingobernables de Japon vs Just 5 Guys: 3 Stars
- Hiroshi Tanahashi vs Kazuchika Okada: 4 Stars
- The Guerrillas of Destiny (Hikuleo & El Phantasmo) © vs BULLET CLUB (Chase Owens & KENTA) (IWGP Tag Team Titles Match): 1.75 Stars
- Bryan Danielson vs Zack Sabre Jr.: 5.5 Stars
- BULLET CLUB War Dogs vs The United Empire (10 Man Tag Team Steel Cage Match): 4.25 Stars

WWE RAW (12.02.2024)
- Sami Zayn vs Shinsuke Nakamura: 3.5 Stars

AEW Dynamite #228 (14.02.2024)
- Dax Harwood vs Jon Moxley: 4.25 Stars
- Adam Copeland vs Daniel Garcia (AEW TNT Title Number One Contender Match): 3.5 Stars
- Matt Taven vs Orange Cassidy (Texas Death Match): 4 Stars

[Misawa~]

AEW Rampage #132 (16.02.2024)
- Jeff Hardy vs Sammy Guevara (No DQ Match): 4 Stars

WWE SmackDown (16.02.2024)
- Dominik Mysterio vs Kevin Owens (Elimination Chamber Qualifying Match): 3.5 Stars

NJPW Presents CMLL Fantastica Mania 2024 Day 6 (18.02.2024)
- Soberano Jr. vs Templario: 4.5 Stars
- Rocky Romero vs Volador Jr.: 4.5 Stars

RevPro High Stakes 2024 (18.02.2024)
- AEW International Title 7 Way Scramble Match: 3.25 Stars
- JJ Gale vs Luke Jacobs: 4.5 Stars
- Mustafa Ali vs Robbie X: 3.75 Stars
- Connor Mills vs Zack Sabre Jr.: 4.5 Stars
- Michael Oku © vs Will Ospreay (RevPro Undisputed British Heavyweight Title Match): 6 Stars

NJPW Presents CMLL Fantastica Mania 2024 Day 7 (19.02.2024)
- Mistico vs Ultimo Guerrero: 3.75 Stars
- Mascara Dorada vs Stuka Jr.: 4.25 Stars

WWE RAW (19.02.2024)
- Cody Rhodes vs Drew McIntyre: 3.75 Stars
- Awesome Truth & DIY vs Judgment Day: 3.75 Stars
- Gunther © vs Jey Uso (WWE Intercontinental Title Match): 4 Stars