Category A
- Wrestler of the Year 2019: [lexicon]Chris Jericho[/lexicon] [AEW]
- Most Outstanding Wrestler 2019: Will Ospreay [NJPW]
- Tag Team of the Year 2019: [lexicon]The Lucha Brothers[/lexicon] ([lexicon]Pentagon Jr[/lexicon]. & [lexicon]Rey Fenix[/lexicon]) [AEW]
- Best On Interviews 2019: [lexicon]Chris Jericho[/lexicon] [AEW]
- Promotion of the Year 2019: New Japan Pro Wrestling (NJPW)
- Most Outstanding TV Show of the Year 2019: AEW Dynamite
- Match of the Year 2019: Shingo Takagi vs Will Ospreay (Best of the Super Junior XXVI Final Match) @ [lexicon]NJPW Best of the Super Junior XXVI Day 15[/lexicon] (05.06.2019)

Category B
- Feud of the Year 2019: Adam Cole vs Johnny Gargano [NXT]
- Most Improved 2019: Lance Archer [NJPW]
- Most Charismatic 2019: [lexicon]Chris Jericho[/lexicon] [AEW]
- Best Technical Wrestler 2019: Zack Sabre Jr. [NJPW]
- Best [lexicon]Brawler[/lexicon] 2019: Tomohiro Ishii [NJPW]
- Best Highflyer 2019: Will Ospreay [NJPW]
- Most Overrated 2019: [lexicon]King Corbin[/lexicon] [WWE]
- Most Underrated 2019: Shorty G [WWE]
- Rookie of the Year 2019: [lexicon]Jungle Boy[/lexicon] [AEW]
- Best Non-Wrestler 2019: Paul Heyman [WWE]
- Best TV Announcer 2019: Kevin Kelly [NJPW]
- Worst TV Announcer 2019: Corey Graves [WWE]
- Best Major Wrestling Show 2019: [lexicon]AEW Double or Nothing 2019[/lexicon] (25.05.2019)
- Worst Major Wrestling Show 2019: WWE Super ShowDown 2019 (07.06.2019)
- Best Wrestling Maneuver 2019: Will Ospreay - Stormbreaker [NJPW] KLICK
- Most Disgusting Promotional Tactics 2019: WWE continuing Business with Saudi Arabia
- Worst TV Show 2019: WWE RAW
- Worst Match of the Year 2019: [lexicon]Bray Wyatt[/lexicon] vs [lexicon]Seth Rollins[/lexicon] © ([lexicon]WWE Universal Title[/lexicon] Hell in a Cell Match) @ WWE Hell in a Cell 2019 (06.10.2019)
- Worst Feud of the Year 2019: [lexicon]Bray Wyatt[/lexicon] vs [lexicon]Seth Rollins[/lexicon] [WWE]
- Worst Promotion of the Year 2019: WWE
- Best [lexicon]Booker[/lexicon] 2019: Gedo [NJPW]
- Promoter of the Year 2019: Tony Khan [AEW]
- Best Gimmick 2019: [lexicon]The Fiend Bray Wyatt[/lexicon] [WWE]
- Worst Gimmick 2019: Shorty G [WWE]
- Box Office Draw 2019: [lexicon]Chris Jericho[/lexicon] [AEW]